Atari 5200 vs Commodore 64 Games System

The Atari 5200 and Commodore 64 were popular gaming systems in the 1980s, each offering a unique gaming experience. The Atari 5200 was known for its advanced graphics and controller design, while the Commodore 64 was praised for its versatility and large library of games.

General information

Atari 5200
Commodore 64 Games System
Introduction :
The Atari 5200 was released in 1982 as a follow-up to the successful Atari 2600. It featured improved graphics and sound capabilities, as well as a unique controller design with a joystick and numeric keypad. While it was not as popular as its predecessor, the Atari 5200 has gained a cult following among retro gaming enthusiasts and is considered a classic console in the gaming community.
Introduction :
The Commodore 64 Games System, released in 1990, was a compact version of the popular Commodore 64 computer. Known for its extensive library of games and affordability, it quickly gained popularity in the gaming market. The console has since become a classic among retro gaming enthusiasts and collectors, with many still enjoying the nostalgic gameplay experience it offers.
Advantages :
  • The Atari 5200 offers a wide variety of classic games.
  • It has a unique controller design with a numeric keypad.
  • The console has a sleek and futuristic appearance.
  • The Atari 5200 is compatible with Atari 2600 games.
  • It provides a nostalgic gaming experience for retro enthusiasts.
Advantages :
  • Extensive library of classic games
  • Retro gaming experience
  • Affordable price point
  • Easy to use interface
  • Durable hardware
Disadvantages :
  • Limited game library compared to other consoles of the time.
  • Fragile controllers prone to breaking easily.
  • Poor graphics and sound quality by modern standards.
  • Lack of third-party support for accessories and peripherals.
  • Limited availability of the console and games for purchase.
Disadvantages :
  • Limited graphics capabilities compared to modern consoles.
  • Lack of online multiplayer functionality.
  • Limited game library compared to newer systems.
  • Outdated hardware may lead to compatibility issues.
  • Limited storage capacity for game downloads.
Year launched : 1982
The Atari 5200 was launched in 1982, offering advanced graphics and gameplay compared to its predecessors. It aimed to compete with other gaming consoles of the time, providing a unique gaming experience.
Year launched : 1982
The Commodore 64 Games System was launched in 1982, offering a range of popular games and becoming a beloved console for many gamers during the 1980s.
Manufacturer : Atari
Atari was the manufacturer of the Atari 5200, a second-generation video game console known for its innovative features and library of games. It was released in 1982 as a competitor to other consoles of the time.
Manufacturer : Commodore International
Commodore International, a well-known electronics company in the 1980s, manufactured the Commodore 64 Games System. It was a popular gaming console that offered a wide range of games for players.
🔴 Popularity : Low.
The Atari 5200 had relatively low popularity compared to other consoles of its time. It faced tough competition from the likes of the Atari 2600 and the emerging Nintendo Entertainment System, resulting in lower sales figures.
🟡 Popularity : Average.
The Commodore 64 Games System was popular during its time, with a significant number of units sold. However, it did not dominate the market compared to some other consoles. It still holds a nostalgic appeal for many retro gaming enthusiasts.
Form factor : Home console.
The Atari 5200 is designed as a home console, meant to be connected to a TV for gaming. It is not intended to be easily portable like handheld consoles.
Form factor : Home console.
The Commodore 64 Games System is designed as a home console, meant to be set up and played in a stationary location rather than being easily portable.
Official website : https://www.atari.com/
Official website : https://www.commodore.ca/


Market and availability

Atari 5200
Commodore 64 Games System
Console markets :
The Atari 5200 was primarily available in North America, with limited availability in some European countries. It was not widely distributed in other regions such as Asia or South America.
Console markets :
🟢 Collectible : Yes.
The Atari 5200 is now considered retro and collectible, with a growing market for vintage gaming consoles. Its unique design and library of classic games contribute to its appeal among collectors and enthusiasts.
🟢 Collectible : Yes.
The Commodore 64 Games System is highly sought after by collectors and retro gaming enthusiasts. Its nostalgic appeal and limited availability make it a valuable addition to any collection.
🟡 Console availability : Average.
The Atari 5200 is moderately available on the secondhand market, with some units in good condition but may be harder to find compared to more popular retro consoles. Prices can vary.
🟡 Console availability : Average.
The Commodore 64 Games System is moderately available on the secondhand market. While not as common as newer consoles, it can still be found through online marketplaces and retro gaming stores.
🟡 Console cost : Average.
The Atari 5200 is considered an average cost console due to its availability on the second-hand market. Prices can vary depending on condition and included accessories, making it a reasonable option for retro gaming enthusiasts.
🟢 Console cost : Low.
The Commodore 64 Games System is considered low in cost due to its age and availability in the second-hand market. It is relatively affordable for retro gaming enthusiasts on a budget.
🟡 Game availability : Average.
Games for the Atari 5200 are somewhat available through online marketplaces and retro gaming stores. However, some titles may be harder to find or more expensive due to the console's age and collectible status.
🟡 Game availability : Average.
Games for the Commodore 64 are available through online marketplaces and retro gaming stores. While some titles may be harder to find, there is a decent selection for collectors and enthusiasts.
🟡 Game costs : Average.
Games for the Atari 5200 are relatively affordable on the second-hand market, with a decent selection available. Prices can vary depending on rarity and condition, but overall, they are considered to be of average cost.
🟢 Game costs : Low.
The relative cost of games for the Commodore 64 Games System is low due to the availability of second-hand games and the lower demand compared to newer consoles, making it a budget-friendly option for retro gaming enthusiasts.


Technology

Atari 5200
Commodore 64 Games System
Architecture : 8-bit.
The Atari 5200 uses an 8-bit architecture, which was common for gaming consoles in the early 1980s. This architecture allowed for basic graphics and gameplay compared to later consoles.
Architecture : 8-bit.
The Commodore 64 Games System uses an 8-bit architecture, which was common for gaming consoles in the 1980s. This architecture allowed for simple graphics and sound capabilities compared to newer consoles.
CPU : MOS Technology 6502C
The Atari 5200 uses the MOS Technology 6502C CPU, which was also used in other popular retro gaming consoles. It is a notable CPU for its performance and role in gaming history.
CPU : MOS Technology 6510
The Commodore 64 Games System uses the MOS Technology 6510 CPU, which is a modified version of the 6502 CPU. It has a clock speed of 1 MHz and is known for its versatility.
Memory : 16 Kb RAM
The Atari 5200 has 16 Kb of RAM, which was considered a decent amount of memory for gaming consoles of its time. However, compared to modern consoles, it is extremely limited.
Memory : 64 Kb
The Commodore 64 Games System has 64 kilobytes of memory, which was considered impressive for its time and allowed for a wide variety of games to be played.
Video output : RF and Composite
The Atari 5200 has RF and Composite video output connections, which may require adapters or converters to connect to modern TVs that typically use HDMI or component inputs.
Video output : Composite and RF
The Commodore 64 Games System has composite and RF video output connections. To connect to a modern TV, an adapter or converter may be needed to convert these analog signals to digital.
⚪ Graphics Processing : Unknown.
The Atari 5200's hardware specifications are not well-documented, so it is unclear if it has a dedicated GPU. Further research may be needed to determine the specifics of its graphics processing capabilities.
🟢 Graphics Processing : Yes.
The Commodore 64 Games System does have a dedicated GPU, providing enhanced graphics capabilities for its time. This allowed for more advanced and visually appealing games to be played on the console.
🔴 Internet connected : No.
The Atari 5200 is not internet connected. Released in the early 1980s, it predates widespread internet connectivity in gaming consoles. It relies solely on physical game cartridges for gameplay.
🔴 Internet connected : No.
The Commodore 64 Games System is not internet connected. It does not have any notable details such as Ethernet or WiFi capabilities for online connectivity.
Game media format : Cartridge.
The primary game format for the Atari 5200 is cartridge-based. Players insert game cartridges into the console to play different games, similar to other consoles of its time.
Game media format : Cartridge.
The primary game format for the Commodore 64 Games System is cartridge-based. Players would insert game cartridges into the console to play different games.


Gaming

Atari 5200
Commodore 64 Games System
Controllers : 4 controllers/players
The Atari 5200 supports up to 4 controllers/players for multiplayer gaming sessions. This allows for competitive or cooperative gameplay experiences on a single console.
Controllers : 2 controllers
The Commodore 64 Games System supports up to 2 controllers for multiplayer gaming experiences. Players can enjoy competitive or cooperative gameplay on this classic console.
⚪ Online multiplayer : Unknown.
The Atari 5200 does not have built-in online multiplayer capabilities. However, there may be third-party options or modifications available for online play, but this is not a standard feature of the console.
⚪ Online multiplayer : Unknown.
The Commodore 64 Games System does not have built-in online multiplayer capabilities, but there may be third-party modifications or emulators that allow for online multiplayer functionality.
🟡 Number of titles : Average.
Game titles for the Atari 5200 were released in an average manner, with a decent selection available. However, due to the console's limited popularity, some titles may be harder to find or more expensive in the secondhand market.
🟡 Number of titles : Average.
Game titles for the Commodore 64 Games System were released in an average manner. While some titles are still widely available, others may be harder to find due to the console's age and limited production.
🟢 Featured games : Yes.
The Atari 5200 has several exclusive and notable games such as
🟢 Featured games : Yes.
The Commodore 64 Games System has several exclusive and iconic games such as 'Impossible Mission', 'The Last Ninja', and 'Boulder Dash', which are highly regarded in the gaming community.


When choosing between the Atari 5200 and Commodore 64, consider your gaming preferences. If you value cutting-edge graphics and innovative controllers, the Atari 5200 may be the better choice. However, if you prefer a wide variety of games and versatility, the Commodore 64 could be the ideal option for you.